What is the MM2 value list?

A community estimate of what each item trades for, in units rather than money. The two main lists are MM2Values, which counts in Seers, and Supreme Values; both are volunteer-maintained and update on a delay.

Why do MM2 item values change?

Supply and demand. An item that still drops gains copies every day while one from a finished event is capped, and sets add demand: each piece of the Ice set is wanted by everyone who holds the other two.

Are MM2 items worth real money?

Only what someone will pay for them. The cash price is the one number you can spend, and it tracks community value loosely at best. Buying or selling items for real money outside Roblox is also against Roblox's Terms of Use: see what that means for your account.

How do you know if an MM2 price is fair?

Compare the same variant across more than one source, and prefer sources that show recent trades. A price far below every comparable listing tells you about the seller, not the item.

3 min read

Aug 7, 2026

MM2 Item Values, Explained

Why the same knife is worth three different numbers depending on who you ask, and how to tell a fair asking price from a hopeful one.

There is no official price list

Murder Mystery 2 has no in-game market and no published prices. Every number you have ever seen attached to an item (on a value list, in a trading server, on a site like this one) is somebody's estimate of what the item trades for.

The three numbers

Ask what an item is worth and you can get three different numbers:

Number	What it is	Keep in mind
Community value	A value list's estimate, in units of its own rather than money	Volunteer-maintained, and updated on a delay
Trade value	What the item gets you in a player-to-player swap today	Moves with events, with what is unobtainable and with what active traders want this month
Cash price	What a buyer will pay in real money	The only one you can spend, and it tracks community value loosely at best

The two main value lists are MM2Values and Supreme Values. MM2Values prices its whole list in Seers, the Godly knife anyone can craft from 20 legendary shards, and Supreme Values uses value units of its own. Either is useful as a compass, not as a price tag.

What actually moves a price

Supply is the big one. Chroma Luger still drops from Gun Box 1, so more copies enter the game every day; Elderwood Scythe stopped at tier 40 of the 2019 Halloween Event pass and no new one has existed since. That is why two items with the same rarity label can be an order of magnitude apart: one is still being minted and one is not.

Demand is the other half, and sets carry a lot of it. Icebreaker pairs with the Godly gun Iceblaster, and Icepiercer completes the Ice set, so each one is wanted by everybody who already holds the other two. A scarcer knife with no set and no following can sit unwanted beside one that has both.

Everything else is friction: how quickly you want the trade done, how much you trust the person on the other side, and whether the seller carries the risk of the trade failing or you do.

Reading an asking price

Compare like for like: the same variant, not just the same name.
Check more than one source, and prefer sources that show recent trades over ones that show opinions.
Treat a price far below every comparable listing as information about the seller, not about the item.
Paying a little over trade value to get an item now, from someone who carries the delivery risk, is a legitimate trade-off. What you are buying at that margin is time.